Lucy’s
134 Northern Blvd, Newburyport, MA
Crema's Take
“Lucy's is a no-frills pastry-and-breakfast spot that nails the basics—their donuts and house-made English muffins are genuinely excellent, and the coffee is solid if straightforward. This is quintessential quick-service fuel for Plum Island vacationers and locals who want a proper breakfast sandwich, not a destination for espresso enthusiasts seeking pour-overs or intricate lattes. It fills a real gap on the island for something better than convenience store coffee, even if it's not trying to be anything more than that.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. Quick-grab spot. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
Stopped in for coffee and water. Had an excellent latte! Ended up trying the local donuts and cookies they had and they were as good as they looked. You could put this place in the middle of other coffee shops and it would still stand out. Amazing service, quality, and…
We are longtime summer vacationers on Plum Island so while not full time locals, practically. We were so excited for a proper coffee shop. This is not that. This is grab and go baked goods and drip coffee and the 4x markup makes it not worth it. Got one iced coffee, a small…
It’s so nice having a quick service option on Plum Island — something we really haven’t had. The breakfast sandwiches were great (on their homemade English muffins), the raspberry scone was delicious, and the iced coffee was fine. Hoping to see an expanded coffee menu once…
Missed opportunity. Was so looking forward to trying out Lucy’s and very disappointed. No espresso, lattes, etc. only drip coffee and ice coffee, there are better options at the Cottage for that. I was really looking Olive’s coffee drinks, which I love, but Lucy’s is just…
The donuts are amazing here. The pastries, great. Didn't get to drink any coffee or tea but my husband said his coffee was good. Breakfast sandwiches were on a brioche type roll instead of an English and made all the difference. There's sandwiches to go and meats and cheeses…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Abraham's Bagels
★ 4.6 (443)
Abraham's Bagels makes legitimately excellent bagels that locals swear rival…
Cafe Sarina
★ 4.6 (224)
Cafe Sarina is built for lingering—a sprawling, light-filled space with a…
NU Kitchen Newburyport
★ 4.5 (345)
NU Kitchen is a genuinely beloved neighborhood spot where the energy feels as…
Best Bagel Newburyport Cafe
★ 4.5 (82)
Best Bagel's house-made bagels are genuinely exceptional—pillowy soft,…