Bloomington Bagel Company
238 N Morton St, Bloomington, IN
Crema's Take
“Bloomington Bagel Company is a bustling campus-adjacent spot where thick, generously-loaded bagels and crispy egg-and-cheese sandwiches draw steady crowds, especially on weekends—though bagel purists might wish they'd slim down their signature rounds. The friendly staff and consistently clean space create welcoming vibes for everything from quick morning grabs to lingering meetups, and their rotating lineup of schmears (like garlic herb cream cheese) and pastries keeps locals and visitors coming back for more than just bagels.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
I saw really good reviews and I was excited to try this place. The staff was very nice. I was unimpressed with my food I ordered the hangover with jalapeño cheddar bagel. I waited about 15 minutes for it to be lukewarm at best! I also ordered a hash brown and drink. Overall the bagel was very bland with so many ingredients and meats on it. My total was $16. A little pricey and long wait for something that was not piping hot.
The bagels aren’t that bad and the location is the best in the city, But those bagels are too goddamn thick and I keep getting told that they’re gonna fix this but they haven’t. I feel like I’m eating more bread than anything else.
In town for a night. A must stop. Always busy on the weekends. Close to campus. Great egg and cheese. Yum yum
I ordered a poppyseed bagel with the garlic herb cream cheese. So yummy! We got our food fast and the restaurant was very clean. Overall amazing vibes, definitely will come back next time I'm in town.
Amazing Lox breakfast bagel sandwich. Update - I have been to Bloomington 3 times now and this has been our first stop every time! Great variety of bagels and schemers, but also their scones are out of this world delicious (more like muffin tops really). The lox bagel is still the winner, I will say, for me. Asiago bagel with their surprisingly-spiced garlic schemer.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Main St Coffee & Kitchen
★ 4.8 (379)
Main St Coffee & Kitchen nails that rare balance of being equally great for a…
Verona Coffee House
★ 4.7 (223)
This Bloomington gem has perfected the art of doing everything well, from their…
Hopscotch Coffee & Kitchen
★ 4.6 (834)
Hopscotch is a beloved Bloomington institution that excels at both precision…
Piccoli Dolci
★ 4.8 (25)
Tuck yourself into this hidden gem nestled in a Bloomington strip mall, where…