The Bake Sale
6923 W Becher St, West Allis, WI
Crema's Take
“This charming West Allis bakery and coffee shop has earned serious devotion for their exceptional pies, particularly the caramel apple pie that reviewers rave about as "the best in years"—generous with quality ingredients and clearly made with care. Beyond the pastries, it's a genuine community gathering spot with a cozy mix of indoor and outdoor seating where locals linger over traditional coffee drinks, making it the kind of place that feels special precisely because it prioritizes quality over trends. The warmth of a family-friendly neighborhood bakery shines through every review, whether people are stopping by for a quick sweet treat or settling in for a leisurely sit.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit, outdoor seating spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
I am not a dessert or sweets person, but this place is amazing. Everything that I have tried is quality and delicious. Highly suggest the key lime pie and caramel apple pie, and they have these adorable mini versions. The lemon blueberry bar and carrot cake are also must buy.…
We enjoyed shopping at this LOCAL coffee shop and bakery. Bought a caramel apple pie to take to a friend’s house. We all agreed It was the BEST pie we had in years. It had a LOT of apples and lovely crust and crumbs. There were many other baked goods that were very…
I discovered The Bake Sale in West Allis through the GoodieBag app and was excited to grab one of their Goody Bags. Mine came with two big pretzels and a pie. Both were delicious! My daughter devoured the pretzels. They were a little stale at first (which is expected with…
This is a cute bakery, bread and coffee spot. It includes some indoor and outdoor seating. It was popular and they were out of some of the items when we arrived mid morning on a Saturday. I tried the cheese and apple pie danish. They both leaned more bread like but were tasty.…
We were across the street for lunch (Archie's Flat Top - separate review), and decided to stop over to check out the bakery. What a great treat, literally. This shop both bakery, cafe and coffee shop, all rolled into one. They have several large cases showing off all the…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
The Bread Pedalers
★ 4.8 (292)
This West Allis gem pairs meticulously crafted espresso drinks with an…
Aroma Café
★ 4.7 (247)
Tucked into a quiet West Allis corner with ample parking, Aroma Cafe celebrates…
Elevate Coffee
★ 4.6 (105)
This West Allis gem combines Instagram-worthy aesthetics with genuinely…
Big Straw Cafe
★ 4.5 (110)
Big Straw Cafe is a charming new boba spot in West Allis that's earned serious…