Prairie Cafe & Bakery
Prairie Cafe & Bakery — photo 2
Prairie Cafe & Bakery — photo 3
Prairie Cafe & Bakery — photo 4
Prairie Cafe & Bakery — photo 5

Prairie Cafe & Bakery

3109 Pheasant Branch Rd, Middleton, WI

★★★★★4.6(475 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Prairie Cafe & Bakery is a beloved Middleton breakfast destination where the carnitas breakfast burrito has developed a devoted following, and the coffee drinks earn genuine enthusiasm from regulars. The longtime staff members bring a warmth and attentiveness that keeps people coming back, whether you're grabbing a quick coffee or settling in for a leisurely weekend morning in their welcoming space. Cash-only and parking-friendly, this is the kind of neighborhood spot where consistency and genuine care show up in every plate and cup.

What to expect

Light foodMeetingsParkingFull breakfastCash onlySlow sitTraditional drinksQuick grabFamily friendlyPastries

Google Reviews

Sarah Perkins
★★★★★2 months ago

I go out of my way to stop here for the carnitas breakfast burrito. It is my very favorite breakfast in Madison area. The workers are very sweet. Many of them have been there for years. Parking can be tricky if the lot fills up, but I can usually find a table inside and the space is so bright and beautiful. I know the other food and the coffee is good too. But that carnitas burrito has my heart.

Keenon Morris
★★★★★2 months ago

This place was ok the prices weren't that bad as I did get full. I was just curious on what this place would be and how the food would make me feel. Didn't punch me in the face with flavor and kind of bland. Had to add the salt and pepper they provided on the table so I gusee that added some flavor. So I rate it 1 through 10 a solid 6.5. If your looking for simple this is the place for you.

Lauren Feierabend
★★★★★5 months ago

Very tasty food. Welcoming, attentive, and caring staff. I found this place one day when looking for food and its one of my favorite breakfast places. Their coffee drinks are amazing. 11/10 would recommend

jon mead
★★★★★5 months ago

Our usual breakfast place was jammed so we went searching for something new,and we weren’t disappointed The menu and the service were a delight. This is more than just a coffee house , they offer excellent breakfast and lunch choices along with great coffee. The staff here was super friendly and extremely efficient. Despite being super busy they were able to provide an awesome breakfast in record time, I think this is our new favorite breakfast place

Milind Godbole
★★★★★a year ago

Excellent cafe very popular for breakfast and lunch on lazy weekends morning. Great location, seating, a very well laid out menu to select from. We ordered chicken salad, wrap and chicken burgers with coffee and milk shake. Portion and quality was top notch. Must visit if you are in Madison.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS