The Alchemist
1660 Bellefontaine St, Indianapolis, IN
Crema's Take
“Tucked just outside downtown Indianapolis, The Alchemist draws coffee lovers with its modern, beautifully designed interior and solid espresso foundations, though it shines brightest when you catch it at the right moment—expect thoughtfully crafted specialty drinks and a comfortable space perfect for lingering with a laptop. The atmosphere and aesthetic earn consistent praise, but service can be inconsistent, so your experience might depend on timing and staffing, but when things click, the excellent coffee and inviting vibe make it worth the visit.”
What to expect
Espresso-focused, with creative signature drinks. A slow-sit, laptop-friendly spot, good for meetings. Open late. Parking available.
Google Reviews
I was DYING to try The Alchemist… and I’m going to be super honest. I left feeling a little disappointed. Maybe it was just the timing — they had some kind of event going on when I went, so service wasn’t the best. It felt a little chaotic and things took longer than expected.…
The food and atmosphere was amazing, but the staff was pretty rude and spacey. We asked for things like an extra napkin and our waitress rolled her eyes. We had to ask for our checks and boxes multiple times.
I stopped by during a Christmas trip to Indianapolis, and unlike how it looks from the outside, the interior was beautiful and the coffee was excellent. Since it was close to their break time, we didn’t have much time and couldn’t stay long, but it’s a really nice place where…
A cool coffee spot just outside of downtown Indy, about a 5-minute drive from Mass Ave. The cafe has a modern vibe with nice interiors and comfortable seating. Parking is available at the rear of the building, which is a plus. The coffee was good as well. Will recommend for…
It was super cute inside. We weren't greeted when we walked in but was greeted at the counter when placing our order. We stopped in after volunteering at a church down the street. I ordered a carmel hot chocolate. I wasn't too impressed with the flavor. I later purchased two…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Top Out Cafe
★ 4.6 (131)
Top Out Cafe is a genuinely welcoming spot where the baristas—and especially…
Anecdote Coffee
★ 4.9 (783)
Anecdote's baristas treat milk steaming like an art form—every espresso drink…
Bovaconti Coffee
★ 4.8 (754)
Bovaconti is an espresso-focused cafe that strikes that perfect balance between…
Wallingford Coffee
★ 4.9 (124)
Tucked into a charming historic train station in Indianapolis, Wallingford…