Crema's Take
“Goldberg's makes legitimately good New York bagels that locals swear by, but the tiny space gets slammed and service is inconsistent—you might walk out happy or frustrated depending on when you visit. The vegan cream cheese options are limited and a bit bland, and the cramped interior feels more utilitarian than inviting, though takeout or outdoor seating helps. If you're in Sag Harbor and want solid bagels with the understanding that execution varies, it's worth a shot; if you need reliable ambiance or extensive dietary options, skip it.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A quick-grab, outdoor seating spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →Everything was great that we ordered. Can get super busy inside! I can see how service can be hit or miss but we lucked out and had good service this time.
We love Goldberg's for a warm morning bagel with tofu cream cheese and/or to grab a bag to go to create nice bagel spreads at home especially when we have guests over. The service at our Sag Harbor location is always nice and the bagels tasty!
The bagels are great, The veg tofu cream cheese is okay and could use a little more salt and be more tangy. Vegan options are limited. The place is quite small and stays busy. It took more than fifteen minutes for them to complete our order in the morning, and people who placed…
Very good New York bagels right on main street. I wish the inside was a little nicer but it still hits the spot. The Hobo sandwich on a roll is a hearty, savory morning experience to try! The tofu cream cheese is notably good! There is also a small local provisions area inside. …
Lives up to its hype. They are very accommodating to making exactly your order. Every specific detail of each and every bagel was spot on. They randomly sell Mike’s Hot Honey by the bottle which is hard to find and normally something I have to order online. No need to toast the…