Limes and Pies
802 Duval St, Key West, FL
Crema's Take
“Tucked into Key West's charming streets, this beloved spot has become legendary for their Key lime pie—a perfectly balanced masterpiece that lets the bright, natural citrus shine without overwhelming sweetness or gimmicky meringue towers. Beyond the iconic pie, they've built an entire Key lime universe with soft serve ice cream, candies, teas, and treats, all executed with the same care and attention to flavor that keeps locals and visitors making special trips back. The laid-back, welcoming atmosphere pairs beautifully with unhurried conversations over a slice and coffee, making it feel less like a tourist trap and more like a genuine Key West institution.”
What to expect
Specialty coffee. Slow-sit spot. Pastries on the menu.
Google Reviews
The best Key Lime pie on the island and better than Kermit's in my opinion. Extremely balanced, flavorful and texturally superior, a true tropical experience! Very charming and colorful store and excellent service by the owner.
If you’re looking for anything Key lime, this is the place to go. They offer a huge assortment of Key lime items, including candies, confections, teas, ice cream, lotions, Rice Krispies treats, and of course, Key lime pie. We tried a small cup of the Key lime ice cream, and it…
Fantastic Key lime pie! Not too sweet, not too tart! The focus is the pie itself..not the meringue like at other places that might give the illusion of a huge piece. We bought two pies and a key lime cone which my youngest devoured! (Not pictured because it was DEVOURED lol!)
We made a special trip to get the soft serve key lime ice cream and decided to get a slice of pie too. The first impression was amazing. The guy working tonight was extremely personable and kind. We had some conversation and purchased the ice cream and the slice of pie. We…
Loved the key lime pie! Tasted better than kermit’s honestly. Perfect mix of sweet and sour with half lime white chocolate wedge. A bit expensive but comes with free coffee or water!
Got a scoop each of chocolate and cookies’n cream flavors. Would not recommend. Too sweet, not creamy, not rich. Should have went for the key lime sorbet.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Big Coppitt Coffee
★ 5.0 (120)
Big Coppitt Coffee is an authentic Cuban breakfast spot where the cafe con…
Caribbean Coffee Roasters by Caffeine
★ 4.8 (225)
Tucked into Key West's bustling streets, this roastery transforms a simple…
La Grignote
★ 4.7 (2,370)
Tucked into Key West's colorful streets, this French-inspired café serves up…
Key Plaza Creperie - All Day Breakfast & Lunch Key West
★ 4.7 (1,034)
This charming Key West breakfast spot delivers generous, beautifully executed…