Schmackary’s
Schmackary’s — photo 2
Schmackary’s — photo 3
Schmackary’s — photo 4
Schmackary’s — photo 5

Schmackary’s

129 4th Ave, New York, NY

★★★★★4.8(170 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Schmackary's is a beloved cookie destination in Union Square where each day brings a rotating selection of inventive flavors alongside their must-try classic chocolate chip—think butter beer and millionaire shortbread—all baked with that perfect balance of crispy exterior and fresh-from-the-oven warmth. The tiny, window-front space with its cozy stools and genuinely warm staff (regulars rave about Nick, Alexis, and Molly) makes it an ideal quick escape or post-work ritual, whether you're grabbing a box to go or settling in with coffee to linger.

What to expect

Traditional drinksQuick grabMeetingsPastriesSlow sit

Google Reviews

Tricia Mercado
★★★★2 months ago

If you like your cookies thin and crunchy yet feels freshly baked, you must visit Schmackary’s. It’s a great discovery of a cookie place. The classic chocolate chip cookie is a must try, among others. Oh, their hot chocolate is good too. Service was also great!

Peter Lee
★★★★★5 months ago

This place is awesome! Pure magic. Nick, Alexis, and Molly are super friendly also! I always stop by this place after a long day at work. So happy I found this place!

Carter Walsh
★★★★★7 months ago

We got a box of cookies! They were all really good but my favorite was the butter beer one. Very gooey and great flavor! The millionaire shortbread was just ok though

CC
★★★★★8 months ago

I heard Schmackary's cookies were pretty good, but I am sad to say they did not live up to the hype. They had a cute space inside with some stools in front of the window. They had a nice display of cookies and even offer ice cream. The cookies were underwhelming. It didn't help that there was no other customer at the time of visit, so it looked like a ghost town. I wouldn't be surprised if there were flies in their bakery case. It is nice that they have deals when buying two, six, or twelve cookies though. Credit card/Apple Pay accepted. No bathroom. No Wifi.

Sharon H.
★★★★9 months ago

Cookies and snacks in Union Sq. area. It’s about 3 mins walk from 14st station. I feel each day they offer different cookies. I would check the website or call if you are looking for the specific flavor. The classic chocolate chip cookies are always available. I had the classic, it was pretty good. I like the salt on top so it was not over sweet. Chill and neat vibe in the store. Take out only. Nice staff at the counter. Easy and quick snack/dessert place for the neighborhood.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS