Miss Molly's Cafe & Pastry Shop
9201 W Center St, Greenfield, WI
Crema's Take
“Miss Molly's is a charming Greenfield gathering spot where locals line up for generously portioned breakfast sandwiches and pastries paired with carefully crafted lattes—it's the kind of place that fills up fast on Friday mornings because word has gotten out. The relaxed, family-friendly vibe makes it perfect for lingering over coffee with friends, whether you're settled at a table inside or enjoying the outdoor seating on a nice day. Just fair warning: while the coffee and savory items are solid, some of their pastries can be hit-or-miss on freshness, so stick with the biscuit sandwiches and scones if you want a reliably good bite.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Been here a few times in the past. This time, I came with a friend to get a hot beverage and a pastry. Food: They have a large selection of breakfast pastries, including scones, cinnamon rolls, hand pies, and more. There are also some savory items, such as a rosemary biscuit. It was a tough choice, but when in doubt, I go for a scone, and they had a Maple Cinnamon one. I had it warmed up a bit, and it was delicious. These scones are not muffins in disguise, which means the texture is a bit drier and more crumbly—perfect alongside a hot beverage. For my drink, I ordered a London Fog Tea Latte. I was hoping to have it served in an actual ceramic mug, but those are only offered to customers who order drip coffee. That said, they made a very good London Fog, with a little extra lavender and plenty of foam. For my taste, it could have been a bit hotter. Service: Everyone who helped us was kind and helpful and gave us plenty of time to choose the perfect pastries. When ordering the London Fog, they explained how they make theirs and how they would add the extra lavender, which I appreciated. As mentioned above, they do not provide mugs for specialty drinks, using mugs instead to keep track of customers who have paid for bottomless drip coffee. I could bring my own mug from home, but I am not a fan of carrying around coffee shop essentials. Atmosphere: The building is nicely designed on the outside and sits on a corner with plenty of large windows that bring in natural light. It faces north, so you avoid the glaring morning sun. Upon entering, there is a short walk to the counter, where you can view all of the bakery and pastry items. A menu board above clearly displays the breakfast and lunch offerings, making it easy for first time visitors. There are numerous tables that accommodate small groups, and a fireplace with a couple of upholstered chairs offers a cozy seating option. Even after filling up with customers, the noise level was very good, and easy to have casual conversations. A nice visit and a place I would enjoy coming back to.
Came here to use a City Tin/Coffee Passport. All the food looked very good. We got the biscuit breakfast sandwiches and a maple scone and two lattes. Unfortunately the scone was bone dry and brittle. The flavor was great but it really needed to be heated up or made more fresh? Same with the biscuit. The biscuit was quite dry and needed warming up or some kind of sauce to moisten it up. I chose to add ketchup and hot sauce. The cinnamon brown sugar latte was really lacking flavor as well. The staff was super kind and we'll be back to try out some other menu items.
Four of us dropped in Sunday morning for a bite and some coffee. Pleasant, relaxing scene, comfortable seating with outdoor seating weather permitting. Pleasant quick service, nice menu selections and fair prices. Around the table we had the Jalapeño Cheddar Biscuit, Cheddar Bacon Bagel, a Chocolate Chip Toffee Cookie, and a glazed Cinnamon Roll. We each enjoyed our orders which were tasty and well presented with sturdy flatware to use (vs plastic you get in some places!). Drinks included lemonade, and Americanos and the coffee was excellent - robust, favorable and well balanced (better than Starbucks). A great local stop that is kid friendly and which I look forward to visiting again soon.
Just stopped in for 1st time, Miss Molly is a charming little gem that blends cozy ambiance with seriously good coffee and baked goods. I ordered a latte which was great. Unfortunately didn’t have much time to try anything else but everything looked great, and inviting. Friendly staff, warm vibes, and a perfect spot for catching up or getting a bit of work done. Highly recommend if you’re in the area!
Cute little spot! Around 11:30am on a Friday, there was a line when we arrived, and the line kept on coming until we left after eating inside. I think it actually got busier as we were eating. Servers are super nice behind the counter. It's pretty much self service here. Ham swiss and spinach galette was delicious and the regular cup of coffee was nice and hot. Overall great vibes and a pleasurable experience!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
DIA Café
★ 4.8 (110)
This vibrant Greenfield spot brilliantly balances serious espresso…
Better Together Cafe
★ 4.8 (474)
Better Together Café is a warmly welcoming spot where the staff—especially a…
Hillside Coffeehouse
★ 4.8 (266)
Tucked inside a historic schoolhouse, Hillside Coffeehouse radiates genuine…
Blüm Coffee Garden
★ 4.7 (823)
Tucked inside Bluemel's Garden Center, Blüm Coffee Garden is a sun-drenched…