Rustic Goat
2800 W Northern Lights Blvd, Anchorage, AK
Crema's Take
“This Anchorage gem balances cozy, warm hospitality with creative comfort food in a lively atmosphere that's equally welcoming for solo coffee dates or family gatherings. While the kitchen can be inconsistent, standout dishes like their mushroom pizza and house-made hummus with rustic vegetables showcase real care, and the staff's personal touches—like personalized birthday menus with dessert discounts—make you feel genuinely celebrated. It's the kind of place where locals return for the inviting vibe and slow-sit culture, even if not every plate lands perfectly.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
I had such high hopes but they were quickly shattered with every bite. Multiple dishes, all subpar and had to send them back to the kitchen. The Stroganoff was meh as it was too sweet. Instead of creamy and flavorful, the Shrimp Scampi was sweet, tart, and all around gross. Had to send this back to the kitchen in exchange for a simple Apple Arugula salad which was equally as bad. The salad was straight vinegar drowning out all other flavors. All three meals ordered by the two patrons were just bad!!!! I wish I could give a positive review of the food, but there’s nothing.
First time coming here and this place exceeded my expectations. Clean, warm atmosphere . The food was amazing . Definitely recommend the hummus to start and the mushroom pizza . Our server keara made the experience even better. Will definitely be back .
I went for my birthday since it was one of the few "fancy" places open on Tuesdays. They printed out personalized birthday menus which was so cute and it's half off of dessert for birthdays. I got the elk, thai lettuce wraps, and creme brulee and both were very good. My boyfriend got the Kalbi bowl. If I had one slight complaint, its that the creme brulee tasted kind of burnt, like they torched it a little too long. But everything else was good
During a trip through Alaska, we stayed in Anchorage and decided to try this restaurant. We were not disappointed. The atmosphere was really fun and lively. We had to wait a bit before being seated, but only like 10min. There were 3 people in my party and we all got different dishes. They all looked and tasted so good that we all shared some of our food. We also tested multiple desserts and they were also amazing and tasted so fresh! The waitress was also really helped and gave us the run down of the menu. We found out that the chef actually makes changes to and updates the menu based on the season, and it really makes a difference in the quality of the food. Overall we had a really good time and impressed with the food.
The Rustic Goat is a must-try! We ordered several dishes. Hummus – I Loved the rustic veggies that topped the hummus. The hummus had that perfect creamy texture. THE HEAT MISER Pizza – Total standout! The crust was soft and flavorful, and the reindeer sausage with caramelized onions made it next-level delicious. Alaskan Scallops – The curry sauce was sooo good—spicy with a nice kick, so be ready for some heat. Shrimp Scampi – Good, but I’d probably skip it next time and try something new. Overall, super tasty with fun flavor combos that make it worth the visit!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Birch & Alder
★ 4.8 (199)
Tucked just outside Anchorage, this beloved spot combines exceptional coffee…
Chef Wienee Miss Beanee
★ 4.6 (1,516)
Nestled in Anchorage, this beloved diner wins hearts with genuinely warm…
Union Station Cafe
★ 4.6 (364)
Union Station Cafe feels like a cherished neighborhood gathering spot where the…
Cyber City Cafe
★ 4.5 (4,120)
This beloved Anchorage breakfast destination has earned its stellar reputation…