Alimentari Beach Montauk
752 Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY
Crema's Take
“Alimentari Beach is pulling off something rare in Montauk: genuinely excellent Italian food that rivals serious NYC restaurants, anchored by standout wood-fired pizzas and house-made pasta dishes that justify the price. The vibe is effortlessly warm with great natural light, and the staff actually cares about your experience, making it feel like a proper neighborhood spot rather than a tourist trap. If you're willing to skip the mediocre coffee and come for the food instead, this is absolutely worth the detour from the lighthouse.”
Google Reviews
Fantastic atmosphere. The server was incredible! However, the food was lacking in quantity for the price. Purchased the enchiladas, and my 2 year old LOVED them. So much so that he was able to finish the entire plate. This highlights how good the food is but the incredibly small…
We stopped there for lunch on our way to the lighthouse, there was no wait. I ordered the Burrata pizza that was absolutely delicious, the tomato sauce and everything was spectacular. Pizza is a thin crust pizza and the size is good for one person. My husband got a sandwich that…
This is better than any NYC Italian spot I’ve ever been to. We got the Tartufo pizza, Nonis lasagna, cascatelli ragu, calamari, and tiramisu. The cascatelli and calamari are insanely good, textures on point! Please support this amazing gem 😋
The pasta was spot on…we got the ragu and the lasagna, and the portions were generous, and the flavor was on point and needed no additions. The appetizer of the artichokes were perfectly fried and the sauce it came with was a good compliment. My peach spritz was delicious and my…
Our dinner at Alimentari was a true delight. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with large windows that give the space an airy, spacious feel. The service is friendly and attentive, making for a truly relaxing dining experience. Loved the fresh cocktails, the Italian wedge…