Montauk Coffee

Bambi’s Cafe

33 Carl Fisher Plaza

“Bambi's makes the kind of breakfast sandwich that'll have you coming back every day—crusty sourdough, quality…”

Maguro Japanese Market

12 S Etna Ave B

“This is a Japanese market masquerading as a sushi counter, and the chef's commitment to pristine fish quality means…”

Alimentari Beach Montauk

752 Montauk Hwy

“Alimentari Beach is pulling off something rare in Montauk: genuinely excellent Italian food that rivals serious NYC…”

Il Buco Vita - with Café & Alimentari

225 Main St

“Il Buco Vita feels less like a coffee stop and more like stepping into a carefully curated Italian lifestyle—the café…”

Joni's

28 S Etna Ave Store #9 on s.Edison st Between south Etna ave &

“Joni's pulls in a devoted crowd of Montauk regulars who've made it their seasonal breakfast ritual, and for good…”

Left Hand Coffee

83 S Elmwood Ave

“Left Hand Coffee pulls off the rare feat of being a genuinely excellent neighborhood roaster that also happens to sit a…”

Naturally Good

779 Montauk Hwy

“This Montauk spot masquerades as a casual bodega but delivers genuine quality across its coffee, fresh-made wraps, and…”

Montauk General Store

805 Montauk Hwy Unit 3

“Their matcha lattes are genuinely exceptional—the color alone will stop you mid-walk through town—and the vibe strikes…”

Gin Beach Cafe

467 E Lake Dr

“Gin Beach Cafe is a seafood-forward spot where the kitchen clearly knows what it's doing—reviewers rave about…”

Do Not Feed Alligators

696 Montauk Hwy

“Do Not Feed Alligators pulls off the rare feat of being both a serious specialty coffee destination and a genuinely fun…”

Montauk Bake Shoppe

29 The Plaza A

“The jelly croissants here are the real deal—a 50-year legacy that keeps locals and visitors lining up before dawn, and…”

George’s Lighthouse Bar & Grill

1999 Montauk Point State Pkwy

“George's Lighthouse Bar & Grill trades specialty coffee for something better: a genuinely stellar lobster roll with…”

Montauk Market Café and Deli

805 Montauk Hwy

“This spot operates as part grocery store, part café, and entirely dependable for breakfast sandwiches that locals…”

Bluestone Lane Montauk Coffee Shop

786 Montauk Hwy

“Bluestone Lane stands out as Montauk's only spot pulling legitimately strong, clean coffee that tastes like actual…”

Cafe Fuze

45 S Euclid Ave

Goldberg's Famous Bagels

28 S Etna Ave

Hampton Coffee Company

732 Montauk Hwy

“Hampton Coffee Company stakes its reputation on creative, ambitious drinks and a genuinely welcoming vibe that makes…”

Goldberg's

57 Kirk Ave

“Skip Goldberg's unless you're willing to gamble on wildly inconsistent pricing and execution—reviews consistently flag…”