Jeff’s Bagel Run
Jeff’s Bagel Run — photo 2
Jeff’s Bagel Run — photo 3
Jeff’s Bagel Run — photo 4
Jeff’s Bagel Run — photo 5

Jeff’s Bagel Run

1332 Orange Ave, Winter Park, FL

★★★★★4.7(470 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

This Winter Park institution is beloved for its obsessively fresh, daily-made bagels—particularly their cult-favorite Asiago everything paired with onion and chive cream cheese—served by a genuinely warm staff who'll guide you through the menu with real enthusiasm. The quick-grab vibe and full breakfast menu make it a reliable family favorite, though bagel purists should note they don't toast here, keeping things beautifully simple. With a stellar 4.7-star rating built on consistent quality and the kind of personal service that has regulars raving, it's earned its status as a Winter Park staple.

What to expect

Family friendlyPastriesTraditional drinksQuick grabFull breakfast

Google Reviews

Meg A
★★★★★2 months ago

I came into this location today around 10:30. I forgot to ask for names, but from other reviews from today, I’m assuming it was Ella and Caroline. They were both wonderful and extremely nice! From the amount of reviews they have gotten today, I’d say they deserve a raise! I originally wasn’t gonna order a coffee, but one of the girls convinced me too. Great job on upselling and making a connection with the customer. Let your employees know they are valued!

Celine Fedz ALD
★★★★★3 months ago

Jeff’s Bagel Run is my dream breakfast. These bagels are unreal. I’m obsessed with the Asiago everything bagel paired with the onion and chive cream cheese. I’m usually not a fan of untoasted bagels… but these are so fresh and so good that toasted or not, they’re hands down the best bagels I’ve had. Their cream cheese deserves its own shoutout. It’s fluffy, fresh, and nothing like the dense, processed stuff. When I get the onion and chive, I can actually see and taste real chunks of ingredients and I loveeeee that. My fiancé is all about the sweet options and always goes for the cinnamon bagel with cinnamon cream cheese. I also tried their vanilla cinnamon latte with oat milk for the first time and… wow. Easily one of the best coffees I’ve had. As a New Yorker, Jeff’s Bagel Run truly tastes like home. Please open a location in Lake Nona or even Saint Cloud because I’ll be there constantly. Absolute favorite.

Dan Dowling
★★★★3 months ago

Bagels definitely came out hot and fresh. I thought it was a little strange you couldn't get them toasted but it is what it is. Love the "lox in a box". They give you plenty of cream cheese, salmon, capers, tomatoes and even cucumbers. I didn't particularly care for the coffee. It had an odd taste as if someone had added a spice to it of some sort? Anyways they also didn't have decaf which I thought odd, and I didn't ask because I don't drink it. Anyways they seem proud of what they do. A few slight improvements in things would be five stars. Would definitely visit them again.

Desiree Diaz
★★★★★5 months ago

A staple in the heart of winter park. Bagels are made fresh daily! The French Onion bagel was sold out but Max was incredibly kind and helpful, guiding me through the menu with genuine enthusiasm. I ended up with the Cacio e Pepe bagel paired with their vegan chives and onion cream cheese, and wow. As someone who is lactose intolerant, I truly appreciated the thoughtful and delicious selection of vegan options available. It's so refreshing to see a bagel shop embrace inclusive offerings without sacrificing flavor. To top it off, the iced banana bread oat milk latte was the perfect, comforting accompaniment. Jeff's Bagel Run delivers not just on exceptionally fresh food, but also on a welcoming atmosphere that makes you want to return. Highly recommend!

Heather Buckner
★★★★★7 months ago

First visit and many more to come! The bagels were cooked like a dream, nice and soft on the inside and crispy on the outside! I got the Asiago Everything bagel(which are my two favorite bagels all together!) The cream cheese was delicious and what a wide selection to choose from! I got the jalapeño(a slow burn) and the veggie. It made a great combo! Ella took our order and was AWESOME-SAUCE! Awesome customer service with genuine smiles and considerations for our experience.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS