Wicked Island Bakery
7 Bayberry Ct, Nantucket, MA
Crema's Take
“This Nantucket institution is beloved for its rotating cast of exceptional pastries and breakfast items, where devoted regulars return daily hoping to snag the famous morning buns before they sell out. Beyond the stellar baked goods—think flaky croissants, cinnamon rolls, and inventive creations like Toad in the Hole—they pour quality fresh-brewed coffee and serve a full breakfast menu in a casual, family-friendly atmosphere that feels like a genuine community gathering spot. It's the kind of place where the helpful staff know their specialties intimately and where your morning visit genuinely feels worth planning around.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. Quick-grab spot. Full breakfast and pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
We have picked up pastries every day of our vacation here because they’re just SO GOOD! The morning bun in particular has been a smash hit. I don’t know how we’ll survive without them when we leave :)
We picked up 3 croissants and a donut. They were so buttery, flakey, and delicious.
Everything at this bakery is fantastic! We picked up goodies every morning- Morning Buns, Cinnamon Rolls, Morning Glory Muffins, Honey Buns, Chocolate Croissant...it didn't matter if they were out of one. That one thing got substituted with another baked good that was just as…
Had to stop with a name like Wicked how could we walk past. Just had breakfast so not hungry so we got a cinnamon muffin which the helpful lady said was their speciality. It was so flaky and delicious. Well worth the walking distance from the Hy Line dock.
Incredible food. I had the best breakfast pastry of my life here, Toad in the Hole. Unbelievable. And the rhubarb strawberry crumble cake, outstanding! We came for the morning bun but they weren't out of the oven yet, but my husband and I were not disappointed with the other…
We tried 4 items: morning bun, pumpkin crumble, nosara spiced scone, and pumpkin scone. I think the morning bun is overrated ($5.35). It's small and absolutely smothered with sugar. Just way too sweet. The system for ordering these is totally non existent. Don't expect to walk…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Yummy
★ 4.5 (118)
This beloved Nantucket spot right on the bike path is as much about the genuine…
Roastd General Store
★ 4.3 (101)
Nestled on Nantucket, this independent roastery brings a genuine general store…
45 Surfside Bakery and Café
★ 4.7 (263)
This beloved Nantucket neighborhood bakery has earned a fiercely loyal…
Nantucket Bake Shop
★ 4.8 (92)
This beloved Nantucket institution excels at what it does best: handmade…