Nantucket Bake Shop
17 Old South Rd, Nantucket, MA
Crema's Take
“This beloved Nantucket institution excels at what it does best: handmade pastries and baked goods that keep locals and visitors coming back, from their legendary cinnamon sugar cake donuts to custom lobster-themed cakes that go above and beyond. The sunny patio and genuine warmth of the staff create an inviting neighborhood gathering spot where reasonably priced treats like fluffy vanilla cupcakes and savory patties feel like homemade indulgences. Whether you're grabbing a quick pastry with your coffee or ordering something special for an occasion, this is where Nantucket's sweet tooth finds authenticity and care.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
Great pastries and love the little patio
2021:When you are looking for a homemade sweet treat this is the place to go! This store is very reasonably priced. I purchased a vanilla cupcake and it was amazing.The cupcake convinced me to special order a birthday cake. I showed the baker the design I wanted with roses, what colors I wanted the roses to be, and when to have it ready by for pick up and she executed it beautifully and in a timely manner! I love it and my family loved it. The staff is very friendly, welcoming and patient. I also got an order of donuts for my family and they were amazing and everyone loved them! The cake taste amazing too! 2022:came back again and ordered a cake. I tried the chocolate cake this year. I’m speechless and my tastebuds are in ecstasy! Best chocolate cake ever! The colors they did for me are perfect. I wanted the cake to match my nautical dish set I was using for my birthday and the staff did the perfect coral and peach toned flowers on the chocolate cake to match! Thank you soooo much for making my Birthday! 2023: I ordered a cake for a bachelorette/birthday party. It was stunning! The girls loved it! Matched the bridal theme perfectly. 10” was plenty big enough for 13 people! Very pleased with this company! They do the best cakes! 2024:Best carrot cake ever!!!
Was blown away by the gorgeous lobster themed cake made by the bake shop! Followed my inspiration and went above and beyond!!! Also was delicious :)
Only tried the Donuts.....and that's why I went in, heard they were good, ......they are great!! Cinnamon Sugar cake donut.... It's a really really good donut, and I have eaten a lot of donuts in a lot of places. Very nice people and good coffee.
Delicious Pattie’s and very sweet ladies. Love it here 💕
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Yummy
★ 4.5 (117)
This beloved Nantucket spot right on the bike path is as much about the genuine…
Wicked Island Bakery
★ 4.4 (211)
This Nantucket institution is beloved for its rotating cast of exceptional…
45 Surfside Bakery and Café
★ 4.7 (255)
This beloved Nantucket neighborhood bakery has earned a fiercely loyal…
Espresso To Go
★ 4.7 (93)
Tucked into Nantucket's bike-friendly scene, this spot delivers that perfect…