Rumors Coffee and Tea House
414 Elk Ave, Crested Butte, CO
Crema's Take
“Rumors Coffee and Tea House in Crested Butte strikes that rare balance of being both a serious craft beverage destination and a genuinely welcoming gathering space, where skilled baristas pour care into everything from their standout cold brew to creative matcha drinks. The cozy, art-filled atmosphere—complete with an on-site bookstore—makes it easy to linger, and the friendly staff seem genuinely invested in helping you discover your next favorite drink at prices that feel almost too good to be true. Just know that while their coffee and specialty teas shine, they source some items pre-made rather than building everything from scratch.”
What to expect
Strong matcha and tea selection, with creative signature drinks, good cold brew. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings.
Google Reviews
This is a really cute bookshop and space! The latte was mid and just bland, like the shots were underpulled or they have a very mild espresso, and maybe that is good for the tourist vibe. Service was super rude and no smiles/friendliness whatsoever, I think the person was just…
This is an exceptional place to get coffee for a number of reasons. First, they have a very good house espresso blend - it is medium roast, but it has a great crema so it holds microfoamed milk/oatmilk etc well. It is therefore very versatile but doesn’t compromise on flavor…
I had the chai latte and was very disappointed they didn’t make it in house — they just reheated an industrial/pre-mixed chai from a bottle. I would expect the chai latte to be made fresh, especially at a tea house and when listed as a ‘Specialty Drink’ on the menu.
The "rumor" is true - unfriendly service if you're not a local. Woman who took my order and made my drink greeted me with "What can I get you?" in a tone I interpreted as annoyance and was noticeably irritated when I asked about the regular Chai versus chocolate Chai. The entire…
The coffee and tea are outstanding—rich, flavorful, and made with care. The staff is friendly, attentive, and happy to help you choose the perfect drink. The cozy seating and welcoming vibe make every visit enjoyable, whether you’re staying for a while or grabbing something on…
Great tea and hot chocolate! Kind and friendly service! Couldn’t believe the prices were so low! Great value! Came back almost daily during our trip we like it so much!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
IV Coffee Trailer
★ 5.0 (12)
Tucked into a trailer just off Elk Avenue, IV Coffee punches well above its…
A Daily Dose
★ 4.3 (181)
Nestled in Crested Butte, A Daily Dose captures that perfect small-town coffee…
T-Bar
★ 4.1 (124)
T-Bar's strength lies in its impressive tea program—dozens of varieties and…
billy barr
★ 4.7 (14)
Tucked into a cozy hotel bar in Crested Butte, this spot shines brightest as an…