The Secret Stash
The Secret Stash — photo 2
The Secret Stash — photo 3
The Secret Stash — photo 4
The Secret Stash — photo 5

The Secret Stash

303 Elk Ave, Crested Butte, CO

★★★★★4.6(2,954 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Nestled in Crested Butte, this beloved spot has cultivated a genuinely warm community hub with thoughtfully curated vintage and globally-inspired decor that reflects the owners' travels—creating an atmosphere that feels both hip and genuinely welcoming. Beyond the inviting vibe, they've earned a reputation for solid comfort food (those wings are legendary) and a creative tipping initiative that turns generosity into a visual celebration streamed across the bar, making every visit feel like part of something special.

What to expect

Family friendlyQuick grabTraditional drinksFull breakfastSlow sitLight foodMeetings

Google Reviews

patrick mackay
★★★★2 months ago

Didn't really eat much... had a nice vibe.. I guess 🙄 Place was pretty pop ular I gotta say. It for sure had a nice hip atmosphere... but not much else I fear... ugh so yeah I didn't really eat anything so I cant much about the food... yeah that'd all I can say about this place... I dont know maybe the food is good I just don't know.. :/

Eric Tofsted
★★★★★2 months ago

Definitely the hot food spot in town! Absolutely love the vibe of this place. Their matched $1000 tipping looks amazing! The receipts are streaming all over the bar. What a fantastic idea. The food itself was incredible. The "Crack" fries are what fills the whole place with the smell of truffle oil. Just purely indulgent. We got the "Texas biggun" and weren't disappointed. This is an incredibly solid supreme pizza with a lot of personality. My only complaint is that the sauce left something to be desired. But such a minor aspect to an amazing meal. I'll definitely be back!

jess w
★★★★★3 months ago

This place is pretty awesome. Walking in, great ambiance- vintage and Indian decor influenced by the owners travels, which is a nice personal touch. The staff at very friendly and attentive. Some special touches you can do- tip the kitchen staff directly and a cool 1000 tip- the owners will match. You can tell the staff like working there. We got the meat pizza, although the pasta the people next to us got looked amazing also. Nice size meatballs, and delicious roasted garlic. Over all great spot and would go again

Chris James
★★★★★3 months ago

First, the place is managed and staffed perfectly. Well done by management. Second, the kitchen is amazing and put out perfect food. (Give them a tip! Plus you get a bell rung when you do.) Third, the waitress we had was amazing and so efficient. Fourth, last, and most important, one of the best pizzas! We are coming back just to get the pizza again. Did a BYO with pepperoni, mushroom, onion, and jalapeño and it was perfect! Just amazing! Wings were spot on and salad good too. And drinks were awesome with full bar.

Shenandoah Gillich
★★★★★6 months ago

Worth the drive in my opinion! The food was good! I LOVED how crispy & moist the wings were & NO BREADING!!! BEST wings I've had in a long time. The pizza was super thin in the middle not good enough to support the toppings. But it was still a good pizza. Our server was on top of everything! Awesome service, food & environment very up beat!

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS