Mayhem's Bookstore & Board Game Café
102 W King St, Lancaster, PA
Crema's Take
“Mayhem's is a genuinely fun third space where the coffee takes a backseat to the real draw: a massive selection of board games, graphic novels, and books that makes it feel like a nerd paradise rather than just another café. The $5 per-person game rental fee is reasonable, the staff are knowledgeable and passionate, and the vibe is perfect for a lazy afternoon with friends, though fair warning that the espresso drinks can be hit-or-miss. If you're going for the games and community over specialty coffee, this spot absolutely delivers.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit, laptop-friendly spot, good for meetings. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
cute place vibe wise! the prices for the board game rental fee isn’t bad at all ($5 a person). however, i have been here two times so far and both of my drinks were mediocre at best — watered down strawberry matcha and an overly foamy “biscoff” latte which tasted like biscoff…
For the most part we had a great experience. I love the idea of a cute hang out spot to sip coffee, read a book or play a game with your spouse or a friend. They have a huge book and game selection. The only thing is that it isn't super cozy and the tables aren't very private if…
Amazing new game cafe downtown! Never even knew it was there and its a little nerd paradise. Awesome place to study or chill during the day. Has a ton of graphic novels to purchase and a wall of great boardgames. Coffee and desserts are great too. Try the jasmine tea! Service…
Super cool and calming place, staff was lovely and had a great time joking and talking with them. Book selection was awesome also, my partner and I had a lovely time talking about various books they had to sell while enjoying our drinks.
Fantastic shop, the bakery and cafe have a great selection at reasonable prices. The staff are amazing and are truly passionate about comic books and board games, they will happily help you find something in their libraries (games or books) that is right for you. The atmosphere…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
The Village Cafe
★ 4.7 (303)
The Village Cafe pulls off that rare trick of being both a serious coffee…
Tomato Pie Cafe
★ 4.5 (1,839)
Tomato Pie Cafe's signature savory pie is worth the trip alone—locals rave…
Lancaster Pie & Coffee
★ 5.0 (302)
The bourbon pecan pie here is legendary enough to justify a detour alone, and…
Lancaster Sweet Shoppe
★ 4.8 (722)
Lancaster Sweet Shoppe excels at seasonal creativity, with rotating ice cream…