Bagel Basket
Bagel Basket — photo 2
Bagel Basket — photo 3
Bagel Basket — photo 4
Bagel Basket — photo 5

Bagel Basket

280 York St, York, ME

★★★★4.3(403 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Bagel Basket is a beloved local spot in York where fresh-baked bagels and breakfast sandwiches are crafted with care and speed, earning genuine praise for their quality that rivals New York standards. The separate dining room with its cozy fireplace creates a welcoming atmosphere perfect for lingering over coffee or grabbing a quick bite, while the genuinely warm staff and efficient service keep regulars coming back. Whether you're ordering ahead for takeout or settling in for a leisurely breakfast, this is the kind of neighborhood gathering place where the food and genuine hospitality are equally memorable.

What to expect

Early hoursSlow sitQuick grabFull breakfastTraditional drinksFamily friendlyMeetingsLight foodPastries

Google Reviews

Acacia Hill
★★★★★3 months ago

I love bagel basket not just because of their fresh baked bagels but because of the employees and atmosphere. There breakfast sandwiches are so delicious and they are fast paced. They listen to your order and they make some really yummy smoothies. You can place orders to go.

An Bl
★★★★★5 months ago

Really good bagel sandwhiches! Great coffee. Clean dining area thats in a separate room from the ordering area. You can order ahead for quicker service. The dining area isntidy, has a nice fireplace and a bathroom. Plenty of parking, great coffee selection and breakfast or lunch menus are available. Fluffy, good bagels! Yum!

Albert Legary
★★★★★5 months ago

Local treasure- fast service woth a real smile, clean and tidy small dining area. Good food, local house made bagels, quickly prepared for takeout, order ahead or eat in the adjacent dining room. Bagel sandwhiches are fresh and hot! Tasty and easy to eat as they mix the meat and cheese into the egg patty. They are generous with portions, and everything is flavorful and good quality. Coffee bar is well stocked with a good variety of properly brewed coffee, new england coffee- very good, and we will admit to being coffee snobs . The bagels are made in house. And are less chewy and dense, a bit more fluffy and cakey. Different style to others. But reallllly nice. Give this place a shot, its worth it. Breakfast for 3 with specialty drinks was under 40$. Good value for travelers.

Talia Hardy
★★★★7 months ago

I ordered a breakfast sandwich and it was completely burnt. I also got a hot cocoa that was cold and honestly tasted like just a cup of milk (it was nearly white in coloring having no chocolate). Wouldn’t recommend this place.

Whitney Tallman
★★★★★7 months ago

BEST BAGEL SANDWICH that I've had since my time in NY. The bagel was soft and fluffy in the middle. The sandwich stayed together when biting into it. It didn't fall apart and the ingredients didn't squeeze out. The bottom of the bagel was crisp like the bottom of a pizza. It was an ideal bagel✨️ Bagel Basket has a wide variety of bagels, cream cheese and sandwich options. I will most definitely be recommending this local gem. Come in and try it! I hope you love it too:) Service was friendly and inviting. I ordered #8 Egg, spinach, tomato & cheese w/ jalapeños cream cheese and a garlic bagel (so much garlic sprinkled on top. Delectable) Highly recommend

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS