Broadway Hot Bagels
Broadway Hot Bagels — photo 2
Broadway Hot Bagels — photo 3
Broadway Hot Bagels — photo 4
Broadway Hot Bagels — photo 5

Broadway Hot Bagels

581 Broadway, Bayonne, NJ

★★★★4.1(275 Google reviews)

Crema's Take

Broadway Hot Bagels has the bones of a classic Jersey bagel shop, with reviewers consistently praising the quality of the bagels themselves when they're made right, though the execution seems inconsistent these days. Unfortunately, the experience is frequently undermined by rushed service and a palpable sense that the operation isn't running at its best, making what should be a straightforward bagel-and-coffee stop feel more stressful than satisfying. If you're willing to take a chance on the bagels on a good day, you might find something worth returning for, but you'd be gambling on both product quality and how welcome you'll feel when you walk in.

What to expect

Quick grabTraditional drinksPastriesFull breakfastLight food

Google Reviews

Joseph Gebhardt
★★★★2 months ago

I think the owner or whoever the guy is, is ready to call it quits no customer service just the feeling of being rushed, asked for a toasted cream cheese bagel, be out bitter I tell him it’s supposed to be cream cheese. He takes the semi melted butter off and replaces it with cream cheese haha what a joke

ILuvFood
★★★★3 months ago

The bacon you use is disgusting. Not crisp, very mush and huge globs of fat smushed together. Disappointing.

RDL
★★★★★3 months ago

My second time here. Bagels are extremely good here and intend to go back.

J M
★★★★a year ago

Broadway Hot Bagels has taken a nosedive in quality over the years. Their bagels have shrunk to a laughable size—more like mini’s. And forget about those stacked Taylor ham and cheese sandwiches from the past; now, you’re lucky if you get anything more than a sad, thin layer. To top it off, the service comes with nothing but attitude. It’s a far cry from what it used to be, and at this point, it’s just not worth the trip.

Angela F.
★★★★a year ago

STAY AWAY..FAR AWAY! I've been to many bagels spots and this by far is the worse. The customer service is sub par and non welcoming, the food not good. I purchased a bacon, egg over easy and cheddar on a scooped out whole wheat. I opened it up and what I received was a dry overcooked bacon and well done egg sandwich and let's not even mention what I saw. I saw the one worker hand the cook (who wasn't wearing any gloves) my cheese. This is disgusting and unsanitary. I can only imagine the rest of this place and how it must be. It's no wonder they only got 4.2 stars as opposed to other places in town.

Crema Reviews

No Crema reviews yet

Been here? Be the first to leave a review in the app.

Write a review on iOS