Boultawn's Bagelry, Cafe & Gallery
226 N Guadalupe St, Santa Fe, NM
Crema's Take
“Tucked into Santa Fe's creative scene, this independent spot pairs fresh-baked bagels and thoughtful sandwiches with an on-site gallery, creating a uniquely local gathering space where the quality of ingredients (especially their green chile offerings and house-made smoothies) shines through despite occasional execution inconsistencies. The bagels themselves are the real draw—praised for being lighter and more approachable than typical dense varieties—and regulars appreciate both the baked goods and the owner's genuine commitment to supporting the community.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
A waste of $. I spent nine dollars for an egg sandwich. I just showed you how much cheese is on the very end and the small egg. It was all bread. All you could taste was bread. And I didn’t buy bread. You could have at least given me one entire piece of cheese. And an egg that could span the entire piece of bread. I want my money back and I’m giving you one star review here. The woman at the counter was nasty. I will not be returning nor will I recommend your place. It’s too bad because I support independent stores in Santa Fe. I ended up going to co-op so I could at least have a full piece of egg that span the entire piece of bread and that egg from the co-op cost me six more dollarsA waste of $. I spent nine dollars for an egg sandwich. I just showed you how much cheese is on the very end and the small egg. It was all bread. All you could taste was bread. And I didn’t buy bread. You could have at least given me one entire piece of cheese. And an egg that could span the entire piece of bread. I want my money back and I’m giving you one star review here. The woman at the counter was nasty. I will not be returning nor will I recommend your place. It’s too bad because I support independent stores in Santa Fe. I ended up going to co-op so I could at least have a full piece of egg that span the entire piece of bread and that egg from the co-op cost me six more dollars
My experience was interesting.. First, the max and cheese with green Chile was very nice. I liked it! They have some interesting offerings on the menu. I came in for a bagel + ALL reviews rave about it so I think I need a 2nd try. The place looks a bit runned down.. but it's also cozy and smallish... Most of the seating was outside.. I would say the girl at the counter wasn't helpful at all. Unfortunately I had to ask many many questions + she seemed very interested in her phone instead of her job + her responses just seemed basic + scripted.. I'd honestly try harder..
Pretty great bagel sandwich. I'm not usually a bagel person because I don't like how dense and chewy they are, but I found this bagel easy to bite into. The cheese on the green chile cheese bagel was nice and crispy and went well with the crispy bacon and super fluffy eggs. The place is pretty small so if you're looking for a place to sit for a while, you might not find a seat inside. There's more seating outside though, and once the sun comes out, it warms up nicely.
If you want to support a wonderful local restaurantuer come enjoy the wonderful baked goods. His bagels are fresh and delicious.
I went here for lunch by chance. I ordered a simple lunch. had a tuna on sourdough, and a blueberry/strawberry smoothie. smoothie was outstanding. ($12). The sandwich ($10) impressed me ... sourdough was thick and toasted perfectly, and the proportions with tuna, mayo, lettuce and tomatoes were perfect. Atmosphere lacked a little. very small. table was sticky. They have outdoor seating options. over heard others talking g Bout how great their bagels and croissants were. they looked very good. But I was happy with trying g this on sourdough and was pleased. Service was ok. menus seemed a bit sparse, as there was one at the counter. you order and pay, then they bring to your table. having adequate menus is a primary item for a restaurant. some minor adjustments can make this place a contender to be a "go-to" destination for the area.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Mr. Bee's Coffee & Teas
★ 4.9 (778)
Tucked away in Santa Fe, Mr. Bee's Coffee & Tea is a warmly welcoming spot with…
Sage Bakehouse
★ 4.8 (695)
Sage Bakehouse is a beloved neighborhood gem where exceptional in-house baked…
Cafe Canyon
★ 4.9 (169)
Nestled along Santa Fe's famous Canyon Road gallery walk, this peaceful refuge…
Bread Shop
★ 4.9 (134)
This Santa Fe institution pairs expertly crafted sourdough with genuinely…