Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop
7328 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis, WI
Crema's Take
“This West Allis institution has built a devoted following by pairing exceptional custom cakes with a genuinely welcoming atmosphere—couples consistently praise their wedding tastings for feeling relaxed and joy-filled rather than high-pressure. Beyond the showstopping occasion cakes, Aggie's serves as a reliable neighborhood spot for fresh pastries and traditional coffee drinks, making it equally perfect for a quick morning grab or a leisurely family visit. The consistency of their craftsmanship, from delicate mini pastries to elaborate custom designs, speaks to a team that treats every order with real care.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. Quick-grab spot. Pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
We used Aggies for our October 2025 wedding and are so happy we did! Our guests still talk about how good the cake was. It was delivered right on time and turned out exactly how we envisioned.
My husband and I chose Aggie's for our wedding cake, and we couldn't be more thrilled with our experience! The cake tasting was delightful--we tasted options in a friendly, low-stress environment and felt supported by their wonderful staff every step of the way. Aggie's was also…
From our initial tasting, we knew we wanted Aggie’s to make our wedding cake. The tasting process was so much fun, and the Aggie’s team was great to work with. We created a cake that was perfectly personalized and intentional, and we got so many compliments on our wedding day.…
We ordered our wedding cake and mini pastries for our reception from Aggie's! Everything about our experience was wonderful from the tasting to the delivery of our order. Our guests absolutely raved about the mini desserts and went back for seconds. The pricing was reasonable…
Aggie's was OUTSTANDING to work with. Not only did they exceed expectations of how we wanted our cake to look and taste, but their customer service was phenomenal. Incredibly easy team to work with, and they were always kind and accommodating. We did our initial tasting and…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Grebe's Bakery
★ 4.6 (1,475)
Grebe's Bakery is a nostalgic neighborhood institution in West Allis where the…
The Bread Pedalers
★ 4.8 (292)
This West Allis gem pairs meticulously crafted espresso drinks with an…
West Allis Cheese & Sausage Shoppe
★ 4.7 (1,896)
While West Allis Cheese & Sausage Shoppe isn't primarily a coffee destination,…
Aroma Café
★ 4.7 (247)
Tucked into a quiet West Allis corner with ample parking, Aroma Cafe celebrates…