Crema's Take
“Bonfire strikes that rare Hamptons balance of genuinely good coffee and approachable prices, with a menu that leans into creative takes like their customizable beach lattes and standout French sandwiches. The crowd skews relaxed and local rather than scene-seeking, making it equally comfortable for a solo work session or a family lunch with dogs in tow. Go for the pastries and prepared sandwiches—they're the real draw here, paired with a patio that makes lingering feel natural.”
What to expect
Specialty coffee, with creative signature drinks. A slow-sit, outdoor seating spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast, pastries, and light food on the menu. Dog friendly. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →Great coffee shop for coffee or lunch. Prepared sandwiches are delicious for lunch try the Black Forest ham Brie cheese on a baguette, it’s delicious! All there items are unique especially there pastries.
Stopped by for lunch and shared a Parisian sandwich and gelato. They were able to customize a beach latte for me to make it less sweet and it came out just right. They encourage visits from responsible dog owners and have a picture board of past furry visitors when you walk in.
This venue in downtown amagansett is adequate. We had the egg, cheese, and duck bacon on a roll. The eggs seemed poached and flavorless. The bacon was also in remarkable. More salt. More fat. SOMETHING!
Unfortunately my coffee/ latte was not great. I originally ordered the honey bee latte and I swear a third of it was honey and syrup. It was terrible so they made me an iced vanilla latte instead (which was very kind) and it was still so sweet and not flavor to the espresso. You…
I absolutely love this place. It has struck the perfect balance between good food, a great atmosphere, wonderful staff and prices that are reasonable for the Hamptons. It's one of the few places out here where u can sit for an hour or two with your laptop, get some work done, …
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Grindstone Coffee & Donuts
★ 4.7 (45)
The peanut butter mocha here is genuinely exceptional—rich, balanced, and the…
S&S Corner Shop
★ 4.8 (95)
S&S Corner Shop punches way above its weight as a genuine community gathering…
Amagansett Coffee Co.
★ 4.8 (33)
This greenhouse coffee shop doubles as a working garden center, so you're…
Montauk Market Springs
★ 4.5 (68)
Montauk Market Springs excels at fresh-baked pastries and made-to-order…