East Hampton Coffee

S&S Corner Shop punches way above its weight as a genuine community gathering spot, serving impeccable Variety Coffee alongside Pain d'Avignon pastries in a…

Bonfire strikes that rare Hamptons balance of genuinely good coffee and approachable prices, with a menu that leans into creative takes like their customizable…

This greenhouse coffee shop doubles as a working garden center, so you're sipping expertly pulled espresso drinks while wandering through blooming flowers and…

The peanut butter mocha here is genuinely exceptional—rich, balanced, and the kind of drink that justifies a detour to East Hampton—and it pairs perfectly with…

Montauk Market Springs excels at fresh-baked pastries and made-to-order sandwiches that punch well above the typical Hamptons price point, with standouts like…

The freddo espresso here is a must-try—it's the kind of creamy, cold coffee drink that locals order on repeat and visitors regret not discovering sooner. Fresh…

John Papas Cafe delivers old-school diner comfort with genuinely excellent execution—the fluffy waffles and classic eggs Benedict taste like they should, the…

Sett makes reliably good espresso drinks and serves a solid breakfast spread in a comfortable, welcoming space—but with only 10 reviews on record, there's not…

The pastries here—especially the creative savory options like kimchi croissant and pistachio-chocolate croissant—are legitimately exceptional and worth the…

Tutto Caffé sources its own beans from Costa Rica and pulls a genuinely good espresso, which earns consistent praise from regulars who make it a Montauk pit…

The Golden Pear trades on East Hampton charm and genuinely warm service, but the pricing is aggressively out of step with what you're getting—$28 for a modest…