Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole

Tucked into a small strip mall, I was not prepared for what was waiting behind the doors at Mamma Toledo’s! Pies, pies and more pies! Any kind of pie you could want! We typically ordered the mini pies because they are perfect for sharing. Our favorites are the key lime, coconut cream, banana cream, triple chocolate, chocolate peanut butter and lemon meringue pies. I’ve purchased their quiches for a few brunch dates and they are always a hit. I really don’t think there is anything at Mamma Toledos that isn’t a delicious masterpiece!

This shop has been part of my weekend for going on two years. My girlfriend and I visit to grab either their chicken pot pie or their hand pies for lunch, and take a new pie every so often. Genuinely some of the best home made style pies I’ve ever had. The owner is very clearly passionate about her craft and is such a joy. I grew up around moon valley and love having this shop as apart of the community. Well worth a visit !

First time getting a pie here. Ordered online which was quick and fairly easy. Pie was ready when I was told it would be. I picked up a small pie as well that was in the display. Main pie was coconut creme: Very good tasting and made well. I was able to serve it without the slices falling over and yet it was soft & creamy. Wasn't super sweet either which is good. The small pie was their triple chocolate pie and it was good as well. Could recognize the different chocolates without being overly rich or super sweet. Small size was a perfect size to share with wife as a desert after dinner. Staff was pleasant & helpful. My expectations may have been too high as I miss my old bakery that closed up. I will definitely get pie here again in future, and may even stop in for breakfast some day.

The upmost delicious home made style pie and quiche. Well loaded burritos. The atmosphere is fenomenal. Service is personalize, friendly, simple with grace. Food quality is high standers. Must stop by get great tasteful pies. Bring a pie to your next gathering from Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole you never be wrong. Hey, take a peek to those cool merchandandise. Spreed the Pie love thru The Moon Valley neighborhood and beyond.

Friendly staff and absolutely amazing savory and sweet pies. Their coconut cream was one of the best and don’t sleep on their green chile pork pie. 🤤