Lucy's Cafe
119 Fitzpatrick St, Key West, FL
Crema's Take
“Tucked away in Key West's quieter corners, this intimate mom-and-pop café delivers authentic Cuban coffee culture alongside fresh, unpretentious food—think perfectly balanced cortaditos and house-made iced tea that rivals the coffee itself. The unhurried atmosphere and thoughtful touches (like honoring requests for less sweetness) make it feel like a genuine escape from the island's tourist bustle, where locals and visitors alike linger over strong, flavorful drinks and surprisingly excellent seafood. It's the kind of place where a simple Cuban coffee becomes memorable, and the whole experience feels genuinely relaxed rather than rushed.”
What to expect
Cold brew standout, with creative signature drinks. A slow-sit spot, good for meetings. Light food on the menu.
Google Reviews
I was looking for a place to have lunch that was off the beaten path. This place suited my needs and my food was delicious. I had the Osacarito and my wife had the fish tacos. The prices were very reasonable and we were able to sit inside in the air conditioning. This place…
We had the cuban sandwich, oscarito sandwich, guava and cheese pastry, cuban coffee, and sweet iced tea. Loved all of it, especially the tea! It was so unique and one of the best sweet teas I've had and I'm from the south. The pork on the sandwiches was very well seasoned and…
Didn’t expect much from an iced tea but it was soooo good! They make it in house and I asked for less sweet. It was so fresh. Great alternative for this who don’t drink coffee. The mint gave it a taste of Moroccan tea
Quietly, just our of the way. Fish sandwich was delicious and filling. Cuban coffee, strong and tasty. Good service.
Visit the Kino Plaza for a pick me up at Lucy’s. Ask for a cortadito cuban coffee with sugar and a splash of foamy milk. Go buy a pair of Kino Key West made flip flops.
Lucy’s Café is a very small, quaint spot tucked away from the crowded streets of Key West, just far enough to feel calm and unhurried. The lobster roll was excellent, fresh, simple, and done right. The coffee was strong and memorable, better than expected. A great place to step…
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Cuban Coffee Queen Downtown (Southard and Duval)
★ 4.7 (2,513)
Tucked down a quiet alley off the bustling Duval Street strip, Cuban Coffee…
Tindahan The Little Asian Store
★ 4.9 (495)
The Dirty Tiger and other signature boba teas here are crafted with genuine…
Nine Line Apparel & Black Rifle Coffee Shop - Key West
★ 4.9 (294)
This Key West gem perfectly blends quality coffee culture with laid-back island…
Caribbean Coffee Roasters by Caffeine
★ 4.8 (225)
Tucked into Key West's bustling streets, this roastery transforms a simple…