Sugar and Spice Bakery
900 E 7th St, Bloomington, IN
Crema's Take
“Sugar and Spice Bakery in Bloomington is beloved for custom cakes that turn celebrations into memories, with reviewers raving about their thoughtful designs and quality baking—their carrot cake is particularly noteworthy. The staff brings a genuinely warm, patient energy to this family-friendly spot, though service can be slow during busy times, and it's the kind of place where regulars return for decades (one customer has been buying their Special K Chewies since the 1970s).”
What to expect
Google Reviews
The people are here are so very nice whenever I went there whenever I do not hear me a debit card. The person was really nice. He also was very helpful to which made it a lot of great stuff by all means and also another thing what they do here they’re really good cookies. They have really good coffee. It’s really good all around here which I really do recommend it.
I waited 20 minutes for a smoothie while everyone who ordered ahead of me got their drinks and food before me. I tried to be patient because I figured they were just busy, but after waiting like 18 minutes, a worker finally asked what I had, and it turns out they had not even written my order down. Then, they told me they did not have the vanilla protein powder I literally paid $2 extra for.
I ordered a custom cake for my daughter’s 3rd birthday, and it was absolutely amazing! She loves dinosaurs so I went with triceratops. It’s carrot cake on the inside, and it is the best carrot cake I’ve ever had everyone, especially and including my daughter, loved it!
What a Phenomenal Birthday Cake Experience!! Sugar and Spice Bakery made my daughter's 21st Birthday at IU EXTRA Special by providing a Beautifully decorated Hot Pink Barbie cake as requested Online! The Cake was DELICIOUS and Surprisingly inexpensive for as Lovely as it was! I Highly recommend this Bakery for a Special Occasion Cake! They will not disappoint! Our cake was ready for Pick-up On time on a Sunday afternoon in order to surprise my daughter! We are so Grateful!! Please use Sugar and Spice for your Students!! :) Sincerely, Anne Betterly
I have bought Special K Chewies at Sugar and Spice since I was a student at IU in the 70’s. I love them and they are the reason I go there. Today I bought some for the first time in two years and they are terrible!! They taste like honey, there is no peanut butter flavor at all. I may give them another try in a few months in hopes they go back to the real recipe. But if what I bought today is what will be offered in the future, I won’t be back.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Gables Bagels
★ 4.8 (411)
This beloved Bloomington institution has earned fierce loyalty with its…
The Chocolate Moose
★ 4.6 (1,130)
This nostalgic Downtown Bloomington ice cream shop excels at creating a…
Piccoli Dolci
★ 4.8 (25)
Tuck yourself into this hidden gem nestled in a Bloomington strip mall, where…
Bloomington Bagel Company
★ 4.2 (316)
Bloomington Bagel Company is a bustling campus-adjacent spot where thick,…