Bagelheads
916 E Gregory St, Pensacola, FL
Crema's Take
“Bagelheads has earned fierce loyalty from regulars who return year after year, drawn as much by the warm, welcoming staff as by their carefully crafted bagel sandwiches like pastrami on garlic parmesan—a spot where locals say the quality doesn't match the 3.9 rating. The Pensacola Bay views from the dining room add a special touch to what feels like a genuine neighborhood gathering place, whether you're grabbing a quick drive-thru bagel or settling in for a full breakfast sandwich that's worth parking for.”
What to expect
Google Reviews
My day didn’t start off great, but Bagelheads completely turned it around. I went to pick up some bagels and realized I had looked at the wrong location, so I thought I wouldn’t be able to get them. It was totally my mistake. Even though it was my fault, the staff and the manager were incredibly kind and understanding. They really went out of their way to help me. I had actually ordered the bagels to share with others, so their kindness meant even more to me. Thanks to them, I was able to share the bagels with a happy heart. And the bagels were delicious too! Wonderful people and great service. Highly recommend!
We had a great experience at Bagelheads in Pensacola. The view of Pensacola Bay is magical, the dining room was clean, and all of the employees were very welcoming and friendly. The restroom was clean as well. They told us that their bagels are made fresh every day and discarded.. We went after lunch so it made perfect sense that they were out of a few things. The guy that took our order was quick to offer suggestions in place of the ones we ordered. My son and his mom had plain bagels with enough cream cheese for 4 bagels, I told my son it looked like a cupcake. I had the Turkey club w Bacon. She had hot coffee, I had a very well crafted Iced coffee. Mine was perfect, I went back for another one for the road. The experience was awesome, we will be back. I appreciate a well run business. Cara was one of the employees that took care of us and she was great.
I’ve been coming to bagel heads for over 6 years now and I have no idea how this place has a 3.9. I live in Texas now, but best believe when I am town, this is a must stop I see some commenters complaining about the wait times, something I’ve never encountered here before, I would recommend coming in and having a sandwich while taking in the wonderful view of the bay. This place is such a great vibe, and I had the cinnamon roll warmed that had me cursing out cinnabon for placing me in a choke hold for too long. The bagels are made fresh with so many great flavors sweet and savory as well as the sheeemmeeeerrrr.
Stopped by and ordered a pastrami, egg and a hash brown all on a garlic parmesan cheese bagel. Originally I wanted steak, but they were out of it. But I secretly wanted the pastrami. It did not disappoint. It was so good! There was quite the line, but toe that just meant they were popular and their food was good. I also ordered a mango smoothie and pineapple flavored sweet tea. Both were outstanding. I definitely see myself coming back.
First time going. Drive thru is only for basic bagels with cream cheese, if you want breakfast sandwich you have to park and go inside. Online orders seem very popular here. Staff is friendly and inside is lively and kid friendly. Might breakfast sandwich was amazing, only complaint is they couldn't not apply cream cheese on their steak egg and cheese crunch. So I paid to have it made as my own bagel, and had to buy a bag of chips to get the "crunch", which made my purchase more expensive. Not putting cream cheese on a sandwich should be an easy request. However, food was really good and the smoothie as well. I would come back.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Einstein Brothers Bagels
★ 3.2 (141)
This Pensacola location offers classic bagel shop comfort with an inconsistent…
The Local
★ 4.6 (119)
Nestled near Pensacola Beach, The Local brilliantly blends a neighborhood…
Bistrology
★ 4.9 (6,339)
Bistrology in Pensacola is a genuine neighborhood gem where carefully crafted…
Jitterbug Beverage Company
★ 4.8 (304)
Jitterbug Beverage Company is where Pensacola goes to escape, thanks to…