Crema's Take
“Do Not Feed Alligators pulls off the rare feat of being both a serious specialty coffee destination and a genuinely fun beach hangout, with their matcha drawing particular praise from locals. The vibe is refreshingly unpretentious—friendly staff and a curated selection of beach essentials make it feel less like a coffee shop and more like a casual gathering spot, though the pricing ($19 for two drinks) skews toward the resort-town premium side. If you're in Montauk and want excellent coffee without the stuffiness, it's worth the detour.”
What to expect
Strong matcha and tea selection. A slow-sit, outdoor seating spot, good for meetings. Full breakfast and pastries on the menu. Family friendly.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →so beautiful!!
Great coffee and a lovely spot to relax by the beach. The staff were very friendly and there were plenty of beach essentials for us to choose from!
Best Matcha in Montauk and the friendliest team too !
Great new coffee shop in Montauk. I love the barista, Lauren
$19 for 2 coffees is highway robbery.
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Bambi’s Cafe
★ 4.8 (99)
Bambi's makes the kind of breakfast sandwich that'll have you coming back every…
Alimentari Beach Montauk
★ 4.5 (441)
Alimentari Beach is pulling off something rare in Montauk: genuinely excellent…
Il Buco Vita - with Café & Alimentari
★ 4.6 (42)
Il Buco Vita feels less like a coffee stop and more like stepping into a…
Maguro Japanese Market
★ 4.9 (35)
This is a Japanese market masquerading as a sushi counter, and the chef's…