Crema's Take
“George's Lighthouse Bar & Grill trades specialty coffee for something better: a genuinely stellar lobster roll with crispy fries that justify the drive to Montauk's remote lighthouse setting. This is a casual spot where you're paying for waterfront views and reliable seafood rather than craft coffee, so visit if you want a solid meal with an ocean backdrop, not for a serious caffeine fix. Fair warning that service inconsistencies have been noted in reviews, but the straightforward food and location make it worth a stop if you're already exploring the lighthouse.”
What to expect
Classic coffee drinks done right. A slow-sit spot, outdoor seating. Pastries and light food on the menu. Family friendly. Parking available.
Google Reviews
See all on Google →On October 25, 2025, I was refused service at George’s Lighthouse Bar & Grill while accompanied by my trained and vested service dog. Despite calmly explaining that he is a legally protected service animal under the ADA, the staff — an older woman with blonde hair who appeared…
Was well worth the four hours drive from manhattan to sample one of the best lobster rolls I’ve ever had. However the true star of the show has to be the French fries, crispy for days. Super friendly, nice staff well worth a visit !
Good to have some spot to get some snack or drink nearby lighthouse. As you can see on the map, no place nearby just park trees and ocean so, of course, the tourist attraction places the price point will be higher than regular but people is willing to pay as there are on…
Stopped in for a bite to eat while at the lighthouse. I decided to take my chance with a lobster roll. It was pretty good for $25 and came with the fries. It was not overdone with Mayo and had nice chunks. I prefer a chunky lobster roll compared to a slaw some places out here…
Another delightful place to find in Montauk! Summer hrs till 6pm, 7 on weekends. Pretty views, educational info re conservation. Good menu, and clean public rest rooms. The seagulls expect to be fed!
Crema Reviews
You might also like
Bambi’s Cafe
★ 4.8 (99)
Bambi's makes the kind of breakfast sandwich that'll have you coming back every…
Alimentari Beach Montauk
★ 4.5 (441)
Alimentari Beach is pulling off something rare in Montauk: genuinely excellent…
Il Buco Vita - with Café & Alimentari
★ 4.6 (42)
Il Buco Vita feels less like a coffee stop and more like stepping into a…
Maguro Japanese Market
★ 4.9 (35)
This is a Japanese market masquerading as a sushi counter, and the chef's…